Thought I'd write a little note about my reaction to two news pieces, found both in Japan and abroad.
The
first is the news of Japanese researchers who have discovered that monkeys have dialects. As a linguistics major and lover of fun language news, I look at this article with big eyes and say... Duh. I mean, they say that the discovery is "the first of its kind", but they must mean that it's the first discovery of
monkey dialects, or perhaps even
Japanese monkey dialects. After all, there's already some famous research that shows
honeybees have dialects related to their honey dance. If
bees have dialects in their unspoken communication, I'm sure as hell that other animals have dialects, too.
The
second is about "Memoirs of a Geisha", otherwise known as "Sayuri" in Japan. Apparently, the film has "sparked anger" across both Japan and China. [looking around Tokyo while watching the daily entertainment news following the "Sayuri" premiere] Really? Where? The article doesn't really provide any clear sources of this "anger", outside of unnamed bloggers and an old Japanese man who found it somewhat odd that none of the Japanese characters spoke Japanese.
Now, it could be that there
is lots of seething anger over this movie that I just haven't noticed. But in my opinion, everyone is clearly aware that this is an American movie, made by Americans, based on a book written by an American. Japanese moviegoers to "Sayuri" probably aren't expecting an "authentic" Japanese experience. They have their own movies for that. They're expecting a Hollywood Japanese experience, the same one that made "The Last Samurai" a big hit. Although, having said that, I seriously doubt that the average Japanese person has any clue what the hell real geisha are like, anyway. Last time I was in Kyoto, a passing group of three geisha caused a huge stir as Japanese tourists sprinted away from Kiyomizu Temple to take pictures of the geisha instead.
Not only that, but movies with "pan-Asian" casts have really increased in number in recent years. Ziyi Zhang is huge here, as well; she stars in a series of shampoo commercials where the plays the "ultimate" Asian beauty. My opinion: "Sayuri" (aka "Memoirs of a Geisha") will be a huge hit in Japan, and no one will give a crap that the lead is a Chinese girl speaking English in a glittering, Vegas-esque Japan.
On a side note, the morning entertainment section of the news showed the world premiere red carpet, and I decided that I really like Japanese actress Kaori Momoi. She was poured into this solid black dress that had lots of tube-like things gathered around the top. One long tube hung off the side like a tassle. When asked about her dress, she explained that her theme was "mistress" or "madame" or something similar. Then she gave a coy little smile and pulled the one long tube off of her shoulder. "But of course," she said, twirling the tube dangerously, "you can't be a madame if you don't have a whip." Ah, so not a tassle. Her dress came with its own built-in whip! I do respect a woman who comes prepared...